Many small businesses, charities and organisations in Scotland commission design work from freelancers rather than larger studios. Freelancers can be flexible, direct to deal with and well suited to smaller projects. The relationship works best when both sides have agreed the essentials in writing before work starts: what will be delivered, how feedback works, when payments are due and who owns the result.

This guide explains each of those points, with particular attention to copyright, which surprises many clients. It describes the general position under UK law and common practice. It is not legal advice, and for a significant contract you should consult a solicitor.

Finding and choosing a freelancer

Look at portfolios with your own project in mind. A designer with beautiful packaging work may not be the right choice for an accessible website, and the reverse is also true. Things to look for include the following.

  • Work for organisations of a similar size or sector.
  • Examples of complete identities in use, not just logos on a blank background.
  • Clear explanations of the thinking behind projects.
  • A process they can describe simply.
  • Previous clients you can speak to.

Send each candidate the same brief and ask for a written proposal. Avoid asking for free concept designs as part of the selection. It asks people to work unpaid, and an idea produced without a proper conversation about your business is a poor basis for choosing.

What a written agreement should cover

A contract does not need to be long. Many freelancers use standard terms of business, which may be perfectly reasonable, but read them and ask about anything unclear. The essential points are summarised below.

TopicWhat to agree
ScopeThe exact deliverables, formats and versions included
ProcessStages of the project, such as research, concepts, development and final artwork
RevisionsHow many rounds of changes are included at each stage, and how extra rounds are charged
TimetableDates for each stage, and how delays on either side affect them
Fees and paymentTotal fee or rate, deposit, stage payments and payment terms
CopyrightWhether and when copyright is assigned to you, and what the designer keeps
FilesWhich files you will receive, including any editable masters
Third-party elementsFonts, photographs and illustrations, and who holds their licences
Portfolio useWhether and when the designer may show the work publicly
CancellationWhat happens if either side ends the project early

Scope and revision rounds

Most disagreements in design projects come back to scope. A clear scope lists what is included and, ideally, what is not. “Logo design” could mean a single mark or a complete pack with variants, colour specifications and usage guidance. Be specific.

Revision rounds deserve the same precision. A round usually means a single, consolidated set of feedback that the designer then responds to. Contracts often include a fixed number of rounds at each stage, with additional rounds charged separately. To get the most from each round, follow a few simple habits.

  1. Collect feedback from everyone who has a say before sending it, and resolve contradictions yourself.
  2. Send one written document, not a string of separate messages.
  3. Describe problems rather than prescribing solutions: “the name is hard to read at small sizes” rather than “make it bigger”.
  4. Refer back to the brief, so that feedback is anchored in the agreed objectives.
  5. Separate essential changes from personal preferences.

Changing the brief midway, for example adding a new audience or deciding you also need a website, is not a revision. It is a change of scope and should be agreed separately, in writing, with any effect on cost and timing made clear.

Copyright: who owns the design?

This is the point that catches many small organisations out. Under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, the first owner of copyright in an artistic work, a category that can include a logo or an illustration, is normally its author, meaning the person who created it. The main exception is work made by an employee in the course of their employment, which belongs to the employer. A freelancer is not your employee, so paying for a design does not by itself make you the copyright owner.

To own the copyright, you need an assignment. Section 90 of the Act provides that an assignment of copyright is not effective unless it is in writing and signed by or on behalf of the person assigning it. A friendly email agreeing in principle is weaker than a signed document. Many design contracts provide that copyright transfers to the client on full payment, which is a common and reasonable arrangement.

Without an assignment, you may still have an implied licence to use the work for the purpose it was commissioned for, but the limits of that licence can be uncertain. For a logo you intend to use for years, perhaps register as a trade mark and defend against imitation, clear ownership is important.

Moral rights

Separately from copyright, the Act gives authors moral rights, including the right to be identified as the author and the right to object to derogatory treatment of their work. Moral rights cannot be assigned, but they can be waived in writing. Many design contracts include a waiver so that the client can adapt the logo in future without risk of dispute.

Fonts, photographs and other third-party material

A design may include elements the designer does not own: a commercial font, a stock photograph, an icon set. Copyright in those stays with their creators, and your use depends on the licence. Ask the designer to list third-party elements and to make sure licences are held in your organisation's name where needed, particularly for fonts used on your website.

Portfolio use

Designers usually want to show finished work in their portfolio. That is normally reasonable, but if the project is confidential until launch, or relates to sensitive services, agree when and how it can be shown.

Receiving the files

At the end of the project you should receive everything you need to use the work without returning to the designer for every small task. For an identity, that typically means the following.

  • Logo files in vector formats (SVG, EPS or PDF) and PNG, in all colour versions.
  • Colour values in CMYK, RGB and hex, plus any Pantone references.
  • The names and sources of the typefaces, with licence details.
  • Brand guidelines, even short ones.
  • Templates, if they were included in the scope.

Whether you also receive the designer's working files, sometimes called source or native files, depends on the agreement. Some designers include them, others charge for them or keep them. Settle this at the start. If you may want another designer to edit the work later, editable files are valuable.

Payment terms and late payment

Freelancers commonly ask for a deposit before starting, with the balance on completion or in stages. Agree payment terms in writing and pay on time. For contracts between businesses, the Late Payment of Commercial Debts (Interest) Act 1998 allows suppliers to claim statutory interest on late payments, together with fixed compensation. For many years the statutory rate has been 8 percentage points above the Bank of England base rate, but the government has consulted on reforms to the late payment rules, so check the current position in official guidance. Knowing this helps both sides take payment dates seriously.

Employment status

A freelancer working on a defined project, using their own equipment and working for several clients, is usually self-employed. Questions of employment status can arise where someone works for you regularly, under your direction, over a long period. HM Revenue and Customs provides an online tool, Check Employment Status for Tax, and guidance on the off-payroll working rules, often called IR35. Since April 2021, medium and large clients in the private sector have been responsible for deciding the status of contractors who work through their own limited company, while small clients are exempt and the contractor's company makes the assessment. Take advice if you are unsure.

Ending the project well

When the work is delivered, check every file promptly: open each one, confirm the formats and colour versions, and make sure the copyright assignment is signed once payment is complete. Store the files in at least two places. Note the designer's details and the date of the project in your records, because years later someone will ask who created the logo and whether you own it.

If the relationship worked well, tell the designer, and keep their details for future projects. A designer who already knows your identity can produce new material faster and more consistently than someone starting from scratch.

Frequently asked questions

Can a designer reuse my rejected concepts for other clients?

Unless your agreement says otherwise, copyright in concepts you did not choose usually stays with the designer, and they may be free to use them elsewhere. If that matters to you, raise it in the contract.

What if the designer disappears before handing over files?

Your options depend on the agreement and on what has been paid. This is one reason to request files at each stage and to make sure your organisation holds key accounts and documents. For a dispute, a solicitor can explain your options.

Is a quote accepted by email enough as a contract?

An email exchange can form a binding agreement if the terms are clear and accepted. It is still better to have a single document that sets out all the points above, and a copyright assignment needs to be in writing and signed to be effective.

Should the contract be under Scots law?

If both you and the designer are based in Scotland, it usually makes sense for the contract to say that Scots law applies and that disputes go to the Scottish courts. Copyright law itself is the same across the United Kingdom. A solicitor can advise if the designer is based elsewhere.